2025 NHL Playoffs Betting Preview: Maple Leafs vs. Panthers — Odds, Trends & Top Picks

Dive into the NHL's 2025 playoff landscape, exploring top contenders, potential upsets, and savvy betting tips
Dive into the NHL's 2025 playoff landscape, exploring top contenders, potential upsets, and savvy betting tips

Panthers Favored Despite Leafs’ Home-Ice Advantage

The Toronto Maple Leafs and Florida Panthers are set to clash in the second round of the 2025 NHL Playoffs, rekindling a rivalry that saw the Panthers eliminate the Leafs in five games during the 2023 postseason. Despite Toronto securing home-ice advantage this time, oddsmakers have installed Florida as the series favorite.

  • Series Odds:
    • Florida Panthers: -155
    • Toronto Maple Leafs: +135

This pricing reflects Florida’s status as the defending Stanley Cup champions and their recent dominance over Toronto, including taking three of four meetings in the 2024–25 regular season.

Key Player Props: Matthews, Nylander, Bobrovsky

Auston Matthews and William Nylander have been pivotal for Toronto, each contributing significantly in the first-round series against Ottawa. Bettors should monitor their point and goal props, as both players are expected to be heavily involved in the Leafs’ offensive efforts.

On the other side, Sergei Bobrovsky remains a cornerstone for the Panthers. His performance will be crucial in countering Toronto’s offensive threats. Props on his save totals and goals-against average could offer value, especially considering Toronto’s high shot volume.

Betting Trends & Series History

  • Regular Season Meetings (2024–25):
    • Florida won 3 of 4 games, outscoring Toronto 13–7.
  • Recent Trends:
    • Florida is 8-3 SU in their last 11 games against Toronto.
    • Toronto is 1-4 SU in their last 5 road games against Florida.

These trends suggest a historical edge for Florida, particularly when playing at home.

Betting Picks: Series Outcome, Game 1, and Props

  • Series Outcome:
    Given Florida’s recent success against Toronto and their playoff experience, backing the Panthers to win the series at -155 offers a balance of value and probability.
  • Game 1 Prediction:
    With the series opener in Toronto, the Leafs may leverage home-ice advantage to set the tone. A play on the Leafs’ moneyline for Game 1 could be worthwhile.
  • Player Props:
    • Auston Matthews Over 0.5 Goals: Matthews has been consistent in finding the net, making this a viable prop bet.
    • Sergei Bobrovsky Over 29.5 Saves: Anticipating a high shot count from Toronto, Bobrovsky’s save total is a prop to consider.

Conclusion

This series promises to be a tightly contested battle between two Atlantic Division powerhouses. Bettors should weigh Florida’s recent dominance and playoff pedigree against Toronto’s home-ice advantage and offensive firepower. Monitoring player performances and adjusting strategies as the series unfolds will be key to successful wagering.


Note: All odds and statistics are current as of May 2, 2025, and are subject to change.